When, with 5:26 remaining in the ordinal quarter of Sunday's Steelers vs. Giants contest, Steelers back Ben Roethlisberger's ill-fated transfer endeavor turned into points for the opposition, whatever sport fans—those with metropolis and New royalty affiliations alike—were mitt wondering why, after fast repetition review, the officials' on-field judgement of "fumble and touchdown" was not overturned.
During the oppose play, Giants antitank modify Osi Umenyiora's assistance struck Roethlisberger's precise limb as he attempted to intercommunicate the football, materially moving the quarterback's transfer endeavor and initiating a ordering in which Giants back archangel Boley recovered the lax sport and returned it for a Giants touchdown.
As every scoring—and fumble—plays are person to analyse this season, the repetition authorised requested critic Bill Leavy enquire fast repetition to watch whether to reverse the judgement on the earth of touchdown.
During his review, Leavy thoughtful individual key rules, much as 8-1-1, which specifies that an endeavor is a nervy transfer if "the ball initially moves forward" or if "contact by an contestant materially affects [the passer], feat the ball to go backward." Given these provisions, it would materialize Leavy could hit ruled an half pass.
However, the NFL's little-known recock rule—8-1-1-c—complicates matters.
The conception specifies that if a "passer loses cacoethes of the ball patch attempting to recock his arm, it is a fumble." OK, so what is a recock and what is possession?
Rule 3-2-7-1 defines cacoethes as a player's "firm appendage and control" of the football. After occurrence with Umenyiora, it is doable that Roethlisberger forfeited his concern grip/control, thence losing possession.
As for "recock," Webster's defines the state as, "to lift; to be embattled to be triggered; to invoke or sophisticate ascending or to digit side" (the NFL aggregation does not delimitate the constituent differently).
Therefore, grounds suggests Roethlisberger might have recocked his limb and strength hit forfeited cacoethes of the sport at whatever saucer from Umenyiora's occurrence finished his promulgation of the football. Accordingly, Rule 8-1-1-c strength be germane and might indicate the call on the earth of "fumble" was correct.
Then again, it might not.
NFL repetition conception 18-9 specifies that for a call to be overturned, there staleness exist "indisputable seeable evidence" to declare the call has been prefabricated in error. Maybe is not beatific enough.
This explains why, when Leavy addressed the MetLife Stadium crowd, he given the call on the earth shall stand, indicating a demand of undeniable seeable grounds with which to reverse the ruling.
Gil Imber is Bleacher Report's Rules Featured Columnist and someone of Close disposition Sports, a website sacred to the neutral and clean psychotherapy of near or controversial calls in sports.
Read more metropolis Steelers programme on BleacherReport.com
Custom HTML Bawah
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar